When buying an old hand tool, it's best to have it in your hands to try before you buy.
In the Pittsburgh region, we have The Three Rivers Tool Collectors, which serves as a great resource for old hand tools. Another option for hand tool purchases are retail stores.
I wanted to see if we could create a list of stores, not including internet stores, that specialize in selling vintage hand tools. These antique hand tool stores can include a dedicated store just for hand tools or, also, a well stocked booth within an antique mall. I live in the Pittsburgh area, but often travel to Baltimore, so, my list is weighted more to include shops in the southern Pennsylvania and Maryland region. If you know of a shop not listed below, please add it to the comments.
List of Antique Hand Tool Stores
The Tool Store above the Woodwright's School. Pittsboro, North Carolina. Owned by Ed Lebetkin. This store has the largest selection of hand tools that I have personally yet encountered, almost all in working condition. For comparison purposes, may I introduce a Pittsboro index, indicating the quantity of tools (not necessarily the quality) in a store relative to Ed's. For example, a store containing half the number of items would be a 0.5P.
Antique Crossroads. Hagerstown, Maryland. Solid small collection of some more unusual woodworking tools. 0.2P.
Fayetteville Antique Mall. Fayetteville, Pennsylvania. There are two buildings that have booths with a wide selection of antique hand tools. One building is adjacent to the gas station while the other building is across the street from that building. There are many user tools as well as some collectible tools. 1.5P.
Old Glory Antiques. Frederick, Maryland: Good collection of common woodworking tools. Good place for a new woodworker. 0.3P.
Factory Antique Mall. Verona, Virginia. 0.2P.
I have not had the opportunity to visit the shops listed below:
Cellucci Saleables in The Heritage Antique Center. Adamstown, Pennsylvania
Dowd's Vintage and Antique Tools. Garland, Texas.
The New Boston Tool Room. Kingston, New Hampshire
Falcon-Wood. Sheffield, Massachusetts
Timeless Tools and Treasures. Bennington, New Hampshire
The Mechanick's Workbench. Marion, Massachusetts (by appt. only)
The Great Adirondack Tool Co. Johnstown, New York
Please feel free to add any of your favorite locations or add your input, including the "Pittsboro Index", on some of the above shops in the comments below.